Skip to content

Our methodology

How we rate batteries

A CompareVolt rating is a score out of 10 for one reviewed battery configuration. Here is the fixed rubric behind it: every line, every weight and a worked example.

What the score is

A CompareVolt rating is a number out of 10 for one reviewed battery configuration, such as a set number of modules. We work it out with a fixed rubric from the manufacturer's current Australian documents and our VPP data.

The rubric turns recorded facts into points, so two people with the same facts get the same score. The score is still our opinion, reached by a fixed method. It isn't a measurement.

What we don't do

We have not installed, tested or owned these batteries. We don't measure performance, efficiency, safety or reliability, and we don't score installed price, customer reviews or how quickly a company handles claims. No manufacturer pays for a score or sees one before it is published.

The rubric gives no points for reputation, company size, market share, awards or other sites' ratings, or for claims about safety or reliability.

What the scale means

So far we have rated 38 batteries. Their overall scores run from 4.4 to 8.2.

A score compares what the documents promise. It doesn't predict how a battery will run in your home, and a few tenths is a small difference.

A few rubric lines usually separate a 6 from an 8. A lower score tends to mean a shorter or more conditional warranty, a missing Australian document, or fewer open VPP programs. A higher score tends to mean long warranty terms with few conditions, documented backup and three-phase options, and wide VPP acceptance.

We don't list rated batteries in a numbered order. Each score sits on its own review, and the "How it compares" cards on a review show a compared battery's score when it has one, and one category where the two scores differ.

We are adding ratings review by review. A review without a rating hasn't been scored yet; it doesn't have a low score.

The four categories and their weights

Warranty (30%). The warranty is the longest promise that comes with a battery, and usually the most fully documented. We score its term, the capacity it promises to keep, how much use it allows, and conditions that can cut cover short.

Functionality (35%). What the hardware can do for your home. It has three parts. Power and backup (60%) covers continuous power, backup equipment, backup output and three-phase homes. Capacity and expansion (30%) covers the largest documented system, adding storage later and whether the usable figure is agreed. Enclosure (10%) is the IP code on the datasheet.

VPP readiness (15%). Whether the VPP programs we track accept this battery today, and whether its warranty leaves room for VPP use. Programs open and close, so this category moves more than the others and carries less weight.

Australian backing (20%). Who stands behind the warranty in Australia. We score the local company and its published contacts, its years here, who can lodge a claim, and who pays the costs of an accepted claim.

A battery-only stack can match an all-in-one unit on Functionality. When a separate inverter sets the AC output, the continuous power line loses 0.5, and backup output set by a part the review doesn't fix scores the lower band. An all-in-one unit gains on the backup equipment line when everything for backup is in the box. A stack gains on the three-phase line when its documents list it for a three-phase supply.

The rubric, line by line

Each line turns one recorded fact into points. Warranty, VPP readiness and Australian backing add up their lines to a score out of 10. Functionality's three parts are each scored out of 10 from their own lines, then blended as set out in How the overall score is worked out.

Inputs come from current Australian manufacturer documents, our catalogue and our VPP data. We don't use overseas documents, except the maker's own dated statement of when its Australian business began.

We count 1,000 warranted cycles as 1.0 MWh per usable kWh, and a "one full cycle a day" limit with no MWh figure as 3.65. A kVA rating is read as kW.

Where a warranty has two sets of limits, one for home use and one for other uses, Warranty uses the home-use limit. The other limit is scored once, under VPP readiness.

Warranty · 30% of the overall score

What we recordPoints
Term of the performance warranty (up to 3.0)
15 years or more3.0
12 to 14 years2.5
10 to 11 years2.0
Under 10 years, or not stated1.0
Capacity kept at year 10, or at the end of a shorter term (up to 2.0)
80% or more2.0
70 to 79%1.5
60 to 69%1.0
Under 60%, or not stated0.5
Throughput for home use (storing your own solar, backup), in MWh per usable kWh (up to 3.0)
Unlimited, or 7.3 and over3.0
4.0 to 7.292.5
3.0 to 3.992.0
2.5 to 2.991.5
Under 2.51.0
Can't be worked out from the documents1.0
Conditions: start at 2.0 and take off 0.5 for each one recorded (up to 2.0)
None recorded2.0
One recorded1.5
Two recorded1.0
All three recorded0.5
Cap
The warranty document doesn't name the reviewed model5.0 at most

The three conditions: (a) cover can be cut or lost if the battery goes offline or its monitoring connection lapses; a one-off registration at commissioning doesn't count. (b) The term can start before installation, or is capped or lost by a manufacture, shipment, delivery or activation date. (c) A use or site limit narrower than the datasheet, such as a daily-cycle limit, an installation deadline, a warranty temperature range inside the operating range, or a flat-battery clause.

Functionality, part 1: Power and backup · 60% of Functionality

What we recordPoints
Continuous power of the reviewed configuration (up to 4.0)
10 kW and over4.0
7 to 9.99 kW3.5
5 to 6.99 kW3.0
3.5 to 4.99 kW2.0
Under 3.5 kW1.0
When the figure is a battery DC rating and a part the review doesn't fix (a separate inverter, or a power module chosen at quote) sets the AC output−0.5
Backup equipment (up to 2.0)
Everything needed for backup is in the reviewed configuration2.0
Backup needs an extra box, or comes from a separate inverter1.0
No backup documented0
Backup output documented for the reviewed configuration (up to 2.0)
8 kW and over2.0
5 to 7.99 kW1.5
Under 5 kW, or set by a part the review doesn't fix1.0
No backup0
Three-phase homes (up to 2.0)
The documents list this configuration for a three-phase supply2.0
Single-phase only1.0
Not recorded0.5

Which power figure we use: the system's own AC rating when the reviewed product includes the inverter. Otherwise, the battery's continuous DC rating, or a lower limit the documents give with listed inverters. Where output is a setting, we use the highest setting every current Australian document agrees on. Where the battery limits a larger inverter, we use the battery's limit.

Functionality, part 2: Capacity and expansion · 30% of Functionality

What we recordPoints
Largest documented system, in usable kWh: one stack on one inverter, or the units the system's own controller runs without extra hardware or maker approval (up to 4.0)
50 kWh and over4.0
30 to 49.9 kWh3.5
20 to 29.9 kWh3.0
12 to 19.9 kWh2.0
Under 12 kWh1.0
Adding storage later (up to 4.0)
The warranty expressly permits adding capacity later, with no time limit4.0
A maximum above the reviewed size is documented, and no condition on adding later is recorded3.0
Allowed with a recorded condition, such as the maker's consent, matched charge levels, equal-size units or an installer procedure2.0
First year only, the documents conflict on the limit, or no path is documented1.0
The warranty or manual doesn't allow it0
Usable-capacity figure (up to 2.0)
One figure agreed across current Australian documents2.0
Two current Australian documents differ by more than 1%1.0
The maker states no usable figure, so ours is derived0.5

Where a limit is given in modules or units, we multiply it by the usable kWh of the reviewed module or unit. We don't score the size of the reviewed configuration: a review covers one size from a range, and scoring it would rate our choice, not the product.

Functionality, part 3: Enclosure · 10% of Functionality

What we recordPoints
Enclosure rating (IP code) on the Australian datasheet or manual. The first digit is dust protection, the second is water protection (up to 10.0)
First digit 6 and second digit 5 or more (IP65, IP66, IP67)10.0
First digit 5 or more and second digit 4 or more, short of the band above (IP54, IP55, IP56, IP64)7.0
Anything lower, or not recorded4.0

Where two current Australian documents give different IP codes, or one product has different codes for different compartments, we score the one in the lower band. This line scores the rating on paper. Most manuals still ask for shelter from direct sun and rain.

VPP readiness · 15% of the overall score

What we recordPoints
Open programs in our VPP data that count towards the reviewed line (up to 8.0)
Each program whose list names the line1.5 each
Each program that lists the brand or family without narrowing it1.0 each
Total for this line8.0 at most
Warranty room for VPP use: the MWh per usable kWh that applies when a VPP controls the battery (up to 2.0)
Unlimited, or 4.0 and over2.0
3.0 to 3.991.5
2.5 to 2.991.0
Under 2.50.5
Can't be worked out, or the warranty doesn't name the model0.5
VPP or third-party control excluded0

A program that lists the family but names only other lines doesn't count. Closed programs don't count.

Australian backing · 20% of the overall score

What we recordPoints
Presence (up to 3.0)
A named Australian company (importer, warrantor or registered subsidiary) with a published Australian phone or email3.0
An Australian contact route, but no Australian company recorded2.0
An authorised service partner only1.0
None recorded0.5
Years in Australia, from the earliest dated record (ABR, ASIC or the maker's own dated statement) to the date of the score (up to 2.0)
10 years or more2.0
5 to 9.9 years1.5
2 to 4.9 years1.0
Under 2 years, or no dated record0.5
Claim route in the warranty (up to 2.0)
The owner can lodge a claim directly with the maker or its Australian service partner2.0
Installer first, with a documented route to the maker if the installer is gone1.5
Only the installer or authorised personnel can claim, or no route for the owner is stated0.5
Claim costs for an accepted claim (up to 3.0)
Labour and freight covered3.0
Partly covered: freight only, a cap such as $200, or a rebate1.5
Not stated0.5
Excluded0
Cap
A recorded insolvency event for the Australian company in the last 5 years3.0 at most

These facts belong to the brand, so every rated review of the same brand shares them.

How the overall score is worked out

Functionality = Power and backup × 60% + Capacity and expansion × 30% + Enclosure × 10%, rounded to the nearest half point. A quarter rounds up: 7.75 becomes 8.0, and 7.15 becomes 7.0.

Overall = Warranty × 30% + Functionality × 35% + VPP readiness × 15% + Australian backing × 20%, rounded to one decimal. Halves round up: 6.55 becomes 6.6.

We do the sums in whole numbers of half points and tenths, so no rounding slip in the arithmetic can move a score.

Worked example: Tesla Powerwall 3

Functionality parts
Power and backup 9.0 · Capacity and expansion 9.0 · Enclosure 7.0
Functionality
9.0 × 60% + 9.0 × 30% + 7.0 × 10% = 8.8, rounded to the nearest half point: 9.0
Category scores
Warranty 8.0 · Functionality 9.0 · VPP readiness 8.5 · Australian backing 7.0
Overall
8.0 × 30% + 9.0 × 35% + 8.5 × 15% + 7.0 × 20% = 8.225, rounded to one decimal: 8.2
Score shown
8.2 out of 10

The Tesla Powerwall 3 review shows the facts behind each line under its score.

What Australian backing measures

Australian backing scores four recorded facts:

  • A named Australian company with published contacts.
  • Its years in Australia, from ABR or ASIC records or the maker's own dated statement.
  • The claim route in the warranty.
  • Who pays the costs of an accepted claim.

It doesn't measure company size, the parent company, how well claims go in practice, or whether to trust a company.

Years in Australia and a published contact are scored as facts about local presence. They are not a proxy for reliability or service.

So a smaller importer can score above a global brand here. Take a local company that lets owners claim directly and pays labour and freight. It earns more than a global brand whose warranty sends claims through the installer and doesn't say who pays.

How VPP readiness is counted

We count the open programs in our VPP data that accept the reviewed line. Each program whose list names the line earns 1.5. Each program that lists the brand without narrowing it to certain lines earns 1.0. This line is capped at 8.0.

Closed programs don't count, and neither do programs that name only other lines from the same family. Scores change when programs open or close.

The count covers only the programs we track: eight open programs today. The VPP comparison lists them.

The second line is warranty room for VPP use: the limit, in MWh per usable kWh, that applies when a VPP controls the battery. Unlimited, or 4.0 and over, earns 2.0. Tighter limits earn less, and a warranty that excludes VPP or third-party control earns 0.

When information is missing or documents disagree

A missing fact is never a blank and never a guess. Each line has a band for "not recorded" or "not stated", and the rating card shows "not recorded" beside those points. That band is the lowest one short of a recorded negative, such as "prohibited" or "excluded".

When two current Australian documents give different figures, we score the lower one.

Two caps sit on top. If the warranty doesn't name the reviewed model, Warranty is capped at 5.0. If the Australian company has a recorded insolvency event in the last 5 years, Australian backing is capped at 3.0.

One missing fact can move two categories. A warranty that doesn't name the reviewed model caps Warranty, and it also sets warranty room for VPP use to 0.5.

The largest documented system can be lower than what a battery can grow to. Only a usable kWh figure in a current document counts. A maximum given only as a number of extra units, with no kWh figure, falls back to the largest model of the line in our catalogue.

Editorial adjustments

An editor can move the overall score by at most 0.5 either way. Category scores are never adjusted.

An adjustment must rest on a recorded fact the rubric has no line for, such as a current regulator recall of the reviewed model. It can't restate a rubric line or cite reputation. Its written reason shows on the review under the score, and we record the date it was approved.

Adjustments in force:

What we don't score yet

  • Price. Few manufacturers publish an Australian price, and we have no installed-price data, so a price score couldn't compare like with like.
  • Customer reviews. We don't collect owner reviews with proof of purchase, and other sites' reviews come from self-selected owners.
  • Fire protection. Few documents record it, and a safety score is the hardest number to defend.
  • Cell chemistry. Few reviews record it, and a score for it would stand in for a safety or lifespan claim.
  • Operating temperature. Once recorded, nearly every battery lands in the same band. The warranty conditions line already takes points off a warranty temperature range narrower than the datasheet's.
  • Independent module control and monitoring. We don't yet record these as facts for every battery.

Each could join a later rubric version once we record it for every reviewed battery.

Older models

Some reviews cover lines we couldn't confirm are still sold in Australia. They keep their full score, shown with a grey tag: "Older model · availability not confirmed".

We don't take points off for this. Not being able to confirm that a line is sold isn't evidence that it isn't, so a deduction would rest on no fact.

The tag comes off when we confirm the line is current. No review publishes the structured data that search engines can show as review stars yet, and these reviews won't when we add it.

When scores change

This page sets out rubric 1.0. Each rating card shows the rubric version and the date its score was worked out.

We work a score out again when a warranty, datasheet or VPP list behind it changes, including when a program opens or closes. Each score is pinned in our records, so it can't change without a deliberate update.

A change to the rubric gets a new version number and an entry in the change log.

Change log

  • Rubric 1.0, November 2026. First ratings published.

Corrections

If a fact behind a score looks wrong or out of date, email hello@comparevolt.com.au. Include the review link, the line to check and a supporting source if you have one.

Manufacturers can use the same address. A score changes only when a current Australian document supports the change.

Keep exploring